How to replace a broken floor tile

Difficulty Intermediate Time 2-3 hours Materials $26–$65 Steps 7
Build a guide for my exact job → Get quotes from local pros
Intermediate2-3 hours
Wear safety goggles and knee pads during the process.
Do it yourself
$26–$65
parts & materials, about 2-3 hours of your time
Hire a pro
$150–$300
typical all-in price
Doing it yourself could save roughly $85
Rough estimates for guidance only — actual costs vary by job, materials and local prices. Get real quotes.

Tools you'll need

Tile cutterGrout floatTrowelChiselHammer

Parts & materials

Replacement floor tile
Typically need: 1
$1-$5
per each
Thin-set mortar
Typically need: 1
$10-$20
per bag
Grout
Typically need: 1
$5-$15
per bag
Tile sealer
Typically need: 1
$10-$25
per each

Estimated materials total: $26–$65. Prices vary by region and retailer.

Step by step

  1. 1 Remove the broken tile Use a chisel and hammer to carefully break and remove the broken tile. Be cautious not to damage surrounding tiles. 30 min ChiselHammer Be careful of sharp tile edges.
  2. 2 Clean the area Remove any old mortar and debris from the subfloor to ensure a clean surface for the new tile. 15 min
  3. 3 Apply thin-set mortar Spread a layer of thin-set mortar on the subfloor using a trowel, ensuring an even coat. 15 min Trowel
  4. 4 Set the new tile Place the replacement tile into the mortar, pressing down firmly to ensure good adhesion. 15 min
  5. 5 Allow to cure Let the mortar cure according to the manufacturer's instructions, usually 24 hours. 24 hours
  6. 6 Grout the tile Once the mortar has cured, apply grout between the tiles using a grout float, ensuring to fill all gaps. 30 min Grout float
  7. 7 Seal the grout After the grout has dried, apply a tile sealer to protect the grout from moisture and stains. 15 min

Permits, safety & disposal

Safety rules
  • Wear safety goggles and knee pads.
  • Ensure proper ventilation when using adhesives and sealers.
Legal disposal
  • Dispose of broken tiles at a local C&D landfill or dumpster.
Check locally

Check with Naperville local authorities for any specific disposal regulations.

Rather not do it yourself?

Describe the job and get matched to vetted local pros — free, in seconds, no account needed.

Get local quotes →

This guide is AI-generated for general help and may not fit your exact situation. Know your limits — when in doubt, hire a licensed pro.

More DIY guides

Install peel and stick backsplash tileRegrout bathroom tile floorLay click-together vinyl plank flooringClean out guttersClean and balance pool waterSeal gaps where mice are getting into my houseReplace a broken sprinkler headWinterize my sprinkler system